Monday, January 06, 2014

Batman v. Superman: Helping High Schoolers Understand the Summa

In the Church History Class I teach, we have finally arrived at the Scholastic period.  I simply did not want to gloss over the scholastics without having my students at least try and read St. Thomas Aquinas (we were going to look at the existence of God questions, primarily Book 1, Question 2, Article 3); yet, I was wrestling for a way to try explain Thomas, the scholastic method in a way that they would understand -- I mean an argument free from most technical terms for which the average high school Senior would be familiar.  I wanted the students to first see how the arguments were structured and worked.  After all, Aquinas' Summa is a very foreign style of writing when contrasted to the other books high school seniors read.   Solution:  Batman v. Superman Summa Style.

Book 1 Question 1.  On Victories in Battle


 Article 1:  Whether Superman would win a fight over the Batman.

Objection1: It seems that Superman would defeat the Batman in a fight based solely on his superior superhuman abilities.

Objection 2:  Further Superman gains his strength from the sun and as we know the sun always shines.

Objection 3:  Superman cannot be killed by any means known of today.

On the Contrary, if Superman and the Batman were to face off for a battle of epic proportions, one in which the bards will sing down through the ages, that the victor in deed would be the Batman, for as the saying goes, “The Pen is mightier than the sword.”

I answer that the Batman would have the distinct advantage and easily defeat Superman due to his constant struggle against superior opponents in size, speed, and strength.  As the Apostle says, “In my weakness I am strong.” Furthermore, the Batman has defeated other alien races even after the end of him seems inevitable.  Lastly, the Batman, having been trained in the best universities of the world and having mastered several fighting styles has the tactical and intellectual advantage.

Reply to Objection 1:  It is not might alone that wins battles but also wisdom and strategy, for it is the tortoise that wins the race.

Reply to Objection 2:  As we know, there are places the sun don’t shine, has never shinned, nor will ever shine.

Reply to Objection 3:  The easiest way to defeat Superman is by means of the utilization of kryptonite.  Victory does not necessitate the death o f our opponent.





                                       

29 comments:

Anonymous said...

Fun and clever way to teach Church HIstory! I love it!

If you're at all interested, I have some info (including a rather goofy but worthwhile video about Aquinas and his 5 Ways) on my website, CatholicReligionTeacher.com.

You'll find the St. Thomas Aquinas section about 1/2 way down on this page: http://catholicreligionteacher.com/the-saints/

Keep up the great work!

In Christ,
Greg

Anonymous said...

Another disputation for your consideration: Ought Superman Be Baptized?

Pranavi said...

Nice Blog... Thank you for sharing this information..

Provident Kenworth
Vaswani Menlo Park
Marina Skies

Unknown said...

Kyler Murray is unquestionably entertaining, but that 49ers pass rush is going to keep him hemmed in the pocket and limit what he can do. On offense, the 49ers will grind it out on the ground. Cardinals vs 49ers Live Free

Unknown said...

If Dan Hooker does win, who will he face for the title? Khabib vs Gaethje Live? Only time will tell.

Stills said...

NFL Football Box Score: Statistics from the Watch Texans vs Chiefs Live game played on January 12, 2020.

Unknown said...

I turned up to find his ‘mate’ was Paul McGinley, the Irish golfing legend who won three consecutive Ryder Cup Live Streaming as a player, including one where he beat Tiger, and a fourth when he was captain.

Melanie J. Butler said...

The teams are well prepared for it and it is certain that both teams are going to do well. This is a very important match and it is expected that the two teams are going to Ravens vs Browns 2020 Livee
do well. nobody would be like to be left behind. Many fans cannot imagine how their home team can disappoint them. It is the outcome of the match that would determine which of the teams is better. Already many bookmarkers could be disappointed because anything can happen.

Unknown said...

One of them was the Pittsburgh Steelers, who implemented the 3-4 in 1983 and have remained loyal to the scheme for the last 37 years. Watch Steelers vs Giants Live

Barry W. Donohue said...

The 2019 campaign didn't go the way that the Bears or Lions would've hoped. Detroit finished last in the NFC North for the ... Bears vs Lions Live Bears 2020 Schedule: Matt Patricia's Detroit Lions to host season opener. The Bears are scheduled to open the 2020 regular season at Ford Field, a change of pace after playing in Detroit on Thanksgiving the last two years. Detroit will then head to Chicago on December 6 for a Week 13 matchup.

Kelvin A Ayala said...

UFC lightweight champion Khabib Nurmagomedov is reportedly set to take on Justin Gaethje at UFC 253. The champion will defend his belt on ... UFC 253 Fight Live Stream Reddit Khabib Nurmagomedov Vs. Justin Gaethje Reportedly Taking Place At UFC 253 In September. 2 weeks ago June 10, 2020. Sorry, the video player failed to load ...

James D. Reyes said...

If you are the type that do not want to watch it through the cables then there is an option for you and that is the internet streaming Watch Dolphins vs Patriots option. There are lots of online streaming options that you can use today to watch that game.

Barry W. Donohue said...

How to watch Colts vs. Jaguars: Live stream, TV channel, start time for Sunday's NFL game. By Scout Staff. Nov 17, 2019 at 12:30 pm ET 1 min read ... Jacksonville Jaguars vs Indianapolis Colts Live Game Recap: Colts vs. Jaguars. Relive all the sights and sounds from Lucas Oil Stadium as the Indianapolis Colts defeated the Jacksonville Jaguars 33-13 in week 11.

Melanie J. Butler said...

Some of the stations are free for new subscribers for one week. If you want to watch all the matches that will take place then you have to Los Angeles Chargers vs Cincinnati Bengals Live Streaming watch that through the station and it means that you have to subscribe for one month of three months of continuous use. The option as to which one to use depends on you.

Harry M. Joachim said...

Green flag for the Indy 500 is set to go off at 12:45pm ET on Sunday as Simon Pagenaud is will start from the pole on Row 1. Pagenaud had been ..For cord-cutters who want indyCar Live Stream Free to stream the 2019 Indy 500 live on indy Live Stream 2020 their smart TVs, computers, or mobile devices, you'll have to have access to the ...Streaming options for the Indy 500. Service, Starting monthly cost (USD), What you get. Hulu Live, $44.99 at Hulu, Access to hundreds ...

Floyd Mayweather said...

The Eagles–Redskins rivalry is a rivalry between the Philadelphia Eagles and Washington ... hidePhiladelphia Eagles vs. Washington Redskins Season-by-Season Washington Redskins vs Philadelphia Eagles 2020 Live Stream Online Results. 1930s Philadelphia Eagles vs. Washington Redskins Results. The following is a list of all regular season and postseason games played between the Philadelphia ...

Sue R. Shrader said...

The Falcons defeated the Seahawks 34-31. Seattle Seahawks tight end Jimmy Graham makes a touchdown grab with an Seahawks vs Falcons Live Atlanta defender draped on him during a game on November 20, 2017. Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson prepares to attempt a pass against the Atlanta Falcons during a game on November 20, 2017.

karamela said...

شركة تركيب طارد حمام بالرياض
شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
شركة مكافحة نمل ابيض بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة تسليك مجاري بالرياض
شركة تنظيف مسابح بالرياض


Paul G. Ho said...

Telstra Premiership Round 13 Panthers vs Raiders. Telstra Premiership. Super Saturday Football. Round 13 - Saturday 8th August 2020 Panthers vs Raiders Tickets. Carolina Panthers-Oakland Raiders Tickets. Fans of the National Raiders vs Panthers 2020 Live Football League know that seeing a game in person is the only ...Raiders vs. Panthers Details. The Carolina Panthers and Oakland Raiders are an exciting NFL matchup. Both teams have big name players that bring loads of ...

Star Sports HD said...

How to watch the computer-simulated Kentucky Derby: date, time, live stream. Posted May 02, 2020. American Pharoah. In this May 2, 2015 file photo, jockey . Kentucky Derby Horses Race Live ..The 2019 Kentucky Derby starts at 6:50 p.m. ET on Saturday, May 4. Here's how to watch the Kentucky Derby for free on TV

Billy said...

Web streamlining implies the path toward making a website continuously perceptible on a web crawler's results page. To clarify, a staggering SEO philosophy will put an association's site at the top of the summary on a Google search page, along these lines improving the likelihood that people will visit the site.



https://5euros.eu/service/1575/illustr ... fond-blanc

Change Donald Swenson said...

If this on-and-off playoff record sounds representative of Kirk Cousins, the Vikings' own quarterback -- a guy many consider to be good enough to sustain success but not necessarily great enough to lead a Vikings vs Packers 2020 Live Stream Online deep playoff run -- then you're on to something. Since becoming a full-time starter in 2015, Cousins has never made the playoffs in back-to-back years.

Billy said...

In excess of a site, we are building an effective and customized advanced methodology.
We exhort, we support, we co-pilot ...
Our job is to acquire an outcome in accordance with your goals.



blois tribu and co creation site internet

Billy said...

I love your blog.. vdry pleasant hues and topic. Did you make this site ourself or did you recruit somebody to do it for you? Plz answer ass I'm looking also structure my own bpog and would likme to discover where u got this from. much appreciated о



Situs Judi QQ Online Terpercaya


Daniel said...

Victorians will still get a public holiday the day before the AFL Grand Final Online Free even if the game is played interstate, with the premier declaring Victorians have earnt it.

rhv said...

افضل خدمات المكافحة ورش المبيدات بخميس مشيط وابها بافضل المعدات والاجهزة العالمية
شركة تنظيف موكيت بخميس مشيط
شركة مكافحة حشرات بابها
شركة مكافحة حشرات بخميس مشيط
شركة رش مبيدات بابها
شركة رش مبيدات بخميس مشيط
شركة مكافحة حشرات ببريدة

jayseo said...

There is no doubt that traditional forms of advertising are slowly being replaced by the Internet. Currently,
the most important are the company's activities on social media.



digital marketing agency

Live Stream TvOnline Free said...

Gamesness Your Game Assistant
https://www.gamesness.com/

DEADPOOL GAME – BEST ACTION-ADVENTURE VIDEO
https://www.gamesness.com/deadpool-game/

THE JUMANJI VIDEO GAME| PLAYSTATION 4, PS4 BEST REVIEW
https://www.gamesness.com/jumanji-video-game/

THE DESOLATE VIDEO GAME | BEST SURVIVAL HORROR GAME
https://www.gamesness.com/desolate-video-game/

TOP 10 BEST UPCOMING VIDEO GAMES 2020 | RELEASE DATE, PLATFORM
https://www.gamesness.com/upcoming-video-games/

LION KING GAME 2019: BEST POPULAR DISNEY CLASSIC REVIEW, GAMEPLAY
https://www.gamesness.com/the-lion-king-game-2019/

GAME OF THRONES VIDEO GAME | BEST REVIEW & STORY 2020
https://www.gamesness.com/game-of-thrones-video-game/

RAMPAGE VIDEO GAME AMAZING GAME EVER|CHEAT CODE & REVIEW
https://www.gamesness.com/rampage-video-game-cheat-code-review/

FAMILY GUY VIDEO GAMES |BEST PLAYSTATION 2 AND XBOX REVIEW
https://www.gamesness.com/family-guy-video-games-best-playstation-2-and-xbox-review/

shanto said...

https://ufc-253-72a3b7.ingress-baronn.easywp.com/

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...